【合集】手电对比，Fenix, Streamlight, Olight, Kobalt

CiTY_HuNTeR

9/8/2020 Update

Olight的手电我基本都比较满意了，枪灯还需要多试试再说。反正从之前的Valkyrie PL1，到PL-Mini这几个都有各种各样不尽人意的问题，最后陆续都出了，还是回到了TLR-1 HL。但是这个尺寸也是有点太大了。

现在手头的PL-PRO和TLR1比差不多大，亮度高很多，之前担心的那个磁铁switch其实不需要担心，吸的很牢。摆弄几下感觉不错，但需要实弹实操体验，至少那个QD比当初1代强多了，不会再容易松动。目前发现PL-PRO的一个小问题就是那个固定块的位置。在rifle上都没问题，但是在手枪上，我的两把full size（M&P，SFX）都毫无例外的无法用1913 insert，因为位置别扭，装上就无法lock，只能用GL的那个窄一点的。而TLR1都是用的1913 insert，没任何问题。



---

第三弹更新：48楼
小更新：53楼

---
之前看过很多TK15的youtube，加上FJ也一直很推崇，就买了。

本来周末前送到的，今天才有机会玩玩。

比较了一下这个和以前我在Lowes买过的一个手电。TK15标称亮度400流明，Lowes那个号称亮度170还是180来的。

首先说TK15吧。在没拿出我的老手电前，感觉两者最高的亮度似乎差不多，不过Fenix的做工和密封看起来都不错，难怪有人掉在湖底一个冬天，解冻了捞出来还能亮。另外有适配的pressure switch和亮度转换按钮。这个按钮可以保持持续点亮在上次关闭的level，可是不能维持strobe，每次打开用strobe都要手动长按，有点缺憾。

Kobalt就是在本地的Lowes pickup的，当初花了六十多刀还是八十多来的，比Tk15还便宜一点点。我觉得做工还算不错，只是个头比较大，装枪上会显得过大了。另外续航能力是TK的强项，这方便Kobalt我不清楚。亮度Kobalt只有2档，我后面说。

发几个对比。个子比较小的是TK15

似乎发光单元Kobalt还要大一点。
对了，忘了说，TK是2节CR123A，或者一节18650，Kobalt要3节CR123A，所以还不知道是否能用18650，有了解的么？

下面说说亮度。左边是Fenix Tk15，右边是Kobalt。距离墙大约5米，特意找了一个两面墙距离基本相近的点，排除角度和距离的干扰。

1. Tk从最弱起第二档亮度，Kobalt低亮度

2. Tk 2档，Kobalt高亮

3. TK 3档，Kobalt 高亮

4. TK 4档（最高亮度），Kobalt高亮

能看出，Kobalt的两档亮度是介于TK的1-2，和3-4之间，更接近2和4. TK更亮，聚光形更好，但Kobalt的光晕在看余光位置时似乎更有帮助。

----
可能的误差：
1. TK用的新买的Tenergy18650，还没有充过，只是用的来的时候带的电，可能对亮度有影响，等充过后再测。
2. Tenergy的保护电路不错。我在放电，用TK的3档放了几个小时，现在四档亮度已经不启动了，和三档一样，应该是电池的PCB保护电压的作用

CiTY_HuNTeR

brucewayne 发表于 2013-5-13 21:48
多谢分享，这个和surefire的比如何呀？

Many people said Fenix is Surefire for normal people. Maybe not as rugged as a Surefire, but much cheaper.

CiTY_HuNTeR

brucewayne 发表于 2013-5-13 21:55
的确便宜不少呢。我听说很多人用手电当棍子防身，不知道是不是真的…… ...

I believe a surefire big hammer head would do the job. Not sure about the Fenix. It may dent but should still light up. It can hold the impact of mounting on a gun tho.

CiTY_HuNTeR

brucewayne 发表于 2013-5-13 21:55
的确便宜不少呢。我听说很多人用手电当棍子防身，不知道是不是真的…… ...

If you look closely, both flashlight have a so called "tactical head" on the top. It is designed for forcing into people, may cause some minor damage IMO.

CiTY_HuNTeR

brucewayne 发表于 2013-5-13 22:00
手电不知道是买装手枪上的好，还是手里拿的好。个人还是倾向后者

I bought the Fenix for my rifles (AR, AK). I have compact flash light for pistol as well. One Streamlight TLR-3, and a Viridian X5L. I like the latter. Green laser is awesome, flash light is so so but it has strobe mode.
Yea, handheld style could have more variation and stick it away from your body to reduce the risk of getting shot. But not lined up with gun as a rail mounted light would do. Both have Pros and Cons.

CiTY_HuNTeR

brucewayne 发表于 2013-5-13 21:55
的确便宜不少呢。我听说很多人用手电当棍子防身，不知道是不是真的…… ...

Well, let's say this. If you don't have a bat, you don't have a bat.

That's why I kept this in my trunk.



When my AR500 armor arrived, along with this bat, I could have more chances to break a way out if some s**t happened (no gun allowed in my school).

CiTY_HuNTeR

brucewayne 发表于 2013-5-13 22:30
赞，这个太厉害了

LOL.

And it is much easier to use than any gun or knife. Anyone can swing a bat, even if your aim is as bad as "aiming the head and hitting the balls", it's still a hit, isn't it?

CiTY_HuNTeR

brucewayne 发表于 2013-5-13 22:41
是啊，就是携带不便，也可以作为家防的一种选择。棒球棍已经被列为lethal weapon了

有了CCW后，去学校可 ...

Nope. A gun free zone means, even if you have CCW (most of my colleagues and I do), you cannot bring guns to school, not even if leaving it in your car.

CiTY_HuNTeR

brucewayne 发表于 2013-5-13 22:48
(B) A valid concealed handgun license does not authorize the licensee to carry a concealed handgun i ...

Just checked our laws. Our school don't have more strict rules other than the State Laws. Our state allow teachers to leave it in locked vehicle but not allow students to do so.

(8) A weapon possessed by a license holder which is under the possessor's control in a motor vehicle or which is in a locked compartment of a motor vehicle or one which is in a locked container in or a locked firearms rack which is on a motor vehicle which is being used by an adult over 21 years of age to bring to or pick up a student at a school building, school function, or school property or on a bus or other transportation furnished by the school, or when such vehicle is used to transport someone to an activity being conducted on school property which has been authorized by a duly authorized official of the school; provided, however, that this exception shall not apply to a student attending such school;

(17) Teachers and other school personnel who are otherwise authorized to possess or carry weapons, provided that any such weapon is in a locked compartment of a motor vehicle or one which is in a locked container in or a locked firearms rack which is on a motor vehicle; or

CiTY_HuNTeR

brucewayne 发表于 2013-5-13 23:40
这就没办法了……每个地方都不一样啊

Which means I can carry, lol.

CiTY_HuNTeR

brucewayne 发表于 2013-5-13 08:40
这就没办法了……每个地方都不一样啊
我们学校学生会年初还申请CCW可以carry on campus，结果被暗 ...

那样老师都不敢给分了。

我以前上过一个中国老师的课，老师跟我很好像哥们一样，后来有次吃饭听别人问我玩枪的事，他半开玩笑地说，“这样我还怎么敢给你分啊”

CiTY_HuNTeR

brucewayne 发表于 2013-5-13 07:41
是啊，就是携带不便，也可以作为家防的一种选择。棒球棍已经被列为lethal weapon了

有了CCW后，去学校可 ...

真的假的？我们州运动器材还不限制

CiTY_HuNTeR

brucewayne 发表于 2013-5-27 09:19
求助一下TK15手电用的是18650电池么？到处都找不到好的买啊

是的，一节。

amazon上我买的tenergy的，是当初FJ推荐，因为它的电池自带保护电路。

18650不是锂聚合物电池而是锂离子电池，没那么稳定，所以我觉得有个保护电路不错。你去amazon搜tenergy 18650

CiTY_HuNTeR

brucewayne 发表于 2013-5-27 11:14
谢谢啊，感觉这个水深呢，amazon上都没有好评价的，还有假的，其他店里根本就没有……

Amazon上有两种tene ...

我买的是那种蓝绿色的。你选有prime的，然后找里面是amazon自己卖的那种

CiTY_HuNTeR

brucewayne 发表于 2013-5-27 12:07
我买了另外一个带充电器的，似乎评价都差不多，先试试吧，我也买了点CR123A，对比一下看看。多谢啦 ...

cr123不太禁用。我的18650买回来，余电我用第二强亮度放了一晚上，而且保护电路很不错，电压低了以后，自动调整输出，只能用较弱的档。

CiTY_HuNTeR

brucewayne 发表于 2013-5-31 11:27
不过说明书上说18650谨慎使用，我两个都试试吧，主要防身用，平时估计用得少 ...

是的，因为那个是锂离子，弄得不好会爆炸的，所以我才买的tenergy，里面带保护电路

CiTY_HuNTeR

brucewayne 发表于 2013-5-31 14:07
听着挺可怕的……我的18650 backorder了，先把CR123A用完再说了，买了12节……

我的电池都装个两个大塑料透明文件袋了，各种设备（手电，激光，optic）都是不同的电池，还有手表遥控器之类的（好在我现在主要带的是太阳能表，不用换电池）．

CiTY_HuNTeR

brucewayne 发表于 2014-6-2 14:59
我枪灯和手电都是CR123A，主要是电脑鼠标一个用5号一个用7号很麻烦

optic还有很多纽扣啊，或者aimpoint那个奇怪的电池

CiTY_HuNTeR

brucewayne 发表于 2014-6-2 15:23
aimpoint是标准的3032吧？

我的是DL１／３N，或者叫２Ｌ７６

CiTY_HuNTeR

brucewayne 发表于 2014-6-2 16:16
这个我还真没见过，有点像以前laser pointer的电池

嗯，高度更高。一节便宜的也要好几刀