枪与自杀似乎没什么关系

TFollowerII

今天有这么一个新闻。

编者按：震惊全美的休斯敦华裔四口被残忍枪杀一案尚无破案头绪，俄亥俄州本周再
爆一桩灭门惨案，现年68岁的越战老兵加尔萨在家中枪杀了自己的妻子、女儿和孙女后
自杀身亡。警方在现场发现一把手枪，并认为这是作案凶器。

首先我要说，RIP。

其次，在禁枪派再次兴奋之前，我查了一下国家间年度自杀率的比较。发现头几名的国家，Greenland，Lithuania, South Korea, Guyana, Kazakhstan, China都是禁枪比较严格的国家。下面是头12名（每10万人里每年自杀超过20人）的国家的枪支限制程度。可以看得出来都是禁枪或者比较禁枪的国家：

• In Greenland, only licensed gun owners may lawfully acquire, possess or transfer a firearm or ammunition. An applicant for a firearm licence in Greenland must pass a background check which considers criminal and relationship records
• The regulation of guns in Lithuania is categorised as restrictive
• The regulation of guns in South Korea is categorised as restrictive
• The regulation of guns in Guyana is categorised as restrictive
• In Kazakhstan, civilians are not allowed to possess automatic firearms and handguns
• The regulation of guns in China is categorised as restrictive
• The regulation of guns in Belarus is categorised as restrictive
• The regulation of guns in Slovenia is categorised as restrictive
• The regulation of guns in Hungary is categorised as restrictive
• The regulation of guns in Japan is categorised as restrictive
• In Sri Lanka, only licensed gun owners may lawfully acquire, possess or transfer a firearm or ammunition. In Sri Lanka, authorities maintain a record16 of individual civilians licensed to acquire, possess, sell or transfer a firearm or ammunition
• The regulation of guns in Ukraine is categorised as restrictive
  

我家屏幕小，头1-24名里还没找到美国

翻页，才看到美国和奥地利，英国，加拿大，瑞士，德国，澳大利亚什么的都是一个量级的。

• The regulation of guns in the United States is categorised as permissive
  

这也说明了没有枪的情况下，心理需要帮助的人们仍然会选择用其他方法来自杀。而枪支宽松的国家里，自杀率并没有显著增高的关系。

三，从佐证上看，在聊一聊为何拥抢权很重要里，我提到一个

不过报告警告不安全持枪的风险存在。但是这点没有结论。

我想如果自杀和枪有直接关联的话，这个政府的调查是不会不提的。

happyfrog

好，这可以去给买买提的那帮左逼大脸去了！

TFollowerII

happyfrog 发表于 2014-2-9 06:51
好，这可以去给买买提的那帮左逼大脸去了！

请随便转发。

graycat2006

枪是众多自杀方法的一种，这些人混淆的是自杀率和自杀成功率。及使按成功率来说，用枪跟跳楼，上吊，跳地铁应该差不多，比吃安眠药高。

erdos

可以调查一下
是不是自杀的人中，上吊率高的都是绳子价钱便宜的国家；
跳楼率高的国家都是建筑物平均高度比较高的国家；
吃安眠药率高的国家都是有国家健保，公共医疗的国家 - 呀，那是不是Obamacare会导致吃安眠药自杀率上升呢....